- Open Access
Comparison between anterolateral thigh free flap and jejunal flap for tissue reconstruction in patients underwent resection of pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma after radiotherapy failure: a retrospective study
BMC Surgery volume 21, Article number: 389 (2021)
Anterolateral thigh (ALT) free flap and jejunal flap (JF) were commonly used in tissue reconstruction for pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma (PESCC) with worsening tissue adhesion and necrosis after radiotherapy failure. However, the results of tissue reconstruction and postoperative complications of these two flaps are controversial. The purpose of this study was to compare outcomes between group ALT free flap and group JF in PESCC after radiotherapy failure.
Intraoperative information and postoperative outcomes of patients with PESCC after radiotherapy failure who underwent ALT and JF reconstruction from January 2005 to December 2019 were compared and analyzed.
The defect size of ALT (Numbers, 34) and JF (Numbers, 31) was 36.19 ± 11.35 cm2 and 35.58 ± 14.32 cm2 (p = 0.884), respectively. ALT and JF showed no significant difference in operation time (p = 0.683) and blood loss (p = 0.198). For postoperative outcomes within 30 days both in recipient site and donor site including wound bleeding, wound dehiscence, wound infection, and pharyngocutaneous fistula, ALT free flap and JF showed similar results. Flap compromise (Numbers, 2 VS.3, p = 0.663), flap take backs (Numbers, 1 VS.1, p = 1.000), partial flap failures (Numbers, 4 VS.2, p = 0.674), and total flap failures (Numbers, 0 VS.0, p = 1.000) showed no difference between the two groups. In addition, no significance was found in hypoproteinemia between the two groups (Numbers, 4 VS.2, p = 0.674). ALT free flap was not statistically different from JF in the incidence of dysphagia at the postoperative 6 months (Numbers of liquid diet, 5VS.5; Numbers of partial tube feeding, 6VS.7; Numbers of total tube feeding, 3VS.1, p = 0.790) and 12 months (Numbers of liquid diet, 8VS.7; Numbers of partial tube feeding, 8VS.7; Numbers of total tube feeding, 5VS.5, p = 0.998). The cause of dysphagia not found to differ between the two groups both in postoperative 6 months (p = 0.814) and 12 months (p = 0.845).
Compared with JF, ALT free flap for PESCC patients after radiotherapy failure showed similar results in postoperative outcomes. ALT free flap may serve as a safe and feasible alternative for PESCC patients after radiotherapy failure.
PESCC is a malignant tumor of the head and neck with poor prognosis that invades the hypopharynx . Large tissue defects caused by tumor resection are always a challenge for surgeons [2, 3]. For the patients with radiotherapy failure, the more severe the tissue adhesion, the greater the possibility of lymph node metastasis and distant metastasis . Therefore, extensive invasion makes it impossible to effectively maintain swallowing function after the resection of PESCC lesions, and tracheotomy and neck tissue reconstruction are required to save the lives of the patients [5, 6].
JF and gastric pull-up have been regarded as routine surgical and repair methods for PESCC for a long time [7, 8]. However, the scar contracture caused by radiotherapy on the muscles, blood vessels and nerves within the head and neck tissue limits the use of the methods. At the same time, ALT free flap has become increasingly prominent for the repair and reconstruction of head and neck tumors in recent years . Its moldability has become a huge advantage in rebuilding tissue defects [10, 11]. The present study aimed to analyze the outcomes of short-term and long-term postoperative complications following ALT or JF reconstruction for patients with PESCC after radiotherapy failure.
Patients and methods
This study was approved by the ethics committee of West China Hospital. All patients signed informed consent. The study protocol is performed in accordance with the relevant guidelinesIn this study, the patients with PESCC after radiotherapy failure who underwent tumor resection at West China Hospital, Chengdu between January 2005 to December 2019 were enrolled. All the patients underwent ALT or JF reconstruction. The patients underwent preoperative blood examination, laryngoscopy biopsy, head and neck computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), chest X-ray or CT, and abdominal ultrasound. History of radiotherapy failure was determined by oral questioning, physical examination, head and neck imaging examination, and treatment history. The diagnosis was confirmed by postoperative pathology. Patients who met the following inclusion criteria were selected: male or female, aged 18–75 years; pathology-confirmed PESCC; failure of radiotherapy; no distant metastasis; and no peripheral vascular diseases of the lower limbs, such as arterial stenosis, arterial embolism, thromboangiitis obliterans, and deep venous thrombosis. The exclusion criteria were severe dysfunction of the heart, kidneys or other organs and a history of other malignancies.
All patients were evaluated by the surgeons for gastrointestinal condition and lower limb health, and appropriate repair options were selected. The patient was placed in the supine position after general intravenous anesthesia. AU-shaped incision was made at the level of the neck to the prevertebral fascia to expose and remove the tumor. The lymph nodes were also dissected (Fig. 1A). The ALT flap (The fascia latissima and myofascial fascia were obtuse separated after dissecting the skin and deep fascia, followed by dissection of the musculocutaneous vascular bundle and dissection of the flap) (Fig. 1B, C) or the JF(Pedicled jejunum flap: we made a longitudinal incision in the abdomen to remove the jejunum and blood vessels of appropriate length and anastomosed the remaining jejunum stump) (Fig. 1E–G) was removed to match the size of the defect. We made the ALT flap into a tube with the skin as the inner wall. The ALT or JF was stitched between the remaining pharynx and esophagus. Arterio-venous anastomoses was performed under a microscope (Artery:superior thyroid artery, arteria lingualis, facial artery, fransverse cervical artery; Vein: facial vein, posterior facial vein, vena jugularis externa, vena jugularis interna), and the degree of vascular patency was assessed by the blood vessel color and the skin temperature (Fig. 1D and H). Finally, a drainage tube was placed on the neck for draining blood and secretions. All patients underwent total laryngectomy and permanent tracheostomy because of laryngeal involvement. The skin temperature of the flap area was measured twice daily after surgery and the temperature difference between the operated area and the unoperated area was determined to measure the survival of the flap. In addition, ultrasound was performed in patients with suspected flap necrosis to confirm vascular status.
Blood tests were performed in 1, 3, 5, and 7 days after surgery. Follow-up was performed in every 3 months in the first year after discharge and every 6 months thereafter. Blood tests, laryngoscopy, head and neck CT or MRI were performed on each patient at each follow-up visit. A barium swallow test was usually performed 2 or 4 weeks after the transplant. A liquid diet was initiated if no leakage was identified in the barium swallow test. If the fluid diet went smoothly, the gastric tube was removed, and a solid diet was initiated; otherwise, the gastric tube was retained. Dysphagia is defined as difficulty swallowing solid food and receiving only liquids or relying partly or entirely on tube feeding. Radiotherapy failure was defined as follows: no reduction of tumor after radiotherapy; or tumor progression includes enlargement of tumor size, lymph node metastasis or distant metastasis after radiotherapy; or recurrence after completed radiotherapy.
SPSS 22.0 statistical software was used to analyze the data and the experimental results. All the data were expressed as means ± standard deviation (SD).The data with anormal distribution were analyzed by student's t-test, and the signed-rank test was used to analyze the data with nonnormal distribution. P < 0.05 indicates statistical significance.
In total, 65 patients with PESCC at the age of 62.31 ± 12.57 and 59.48 ± 12.56 years who underwent ALT flap surgery (n = 34; 25 males and 9 females) or JF surgery (n = 31; 23 males and 8 females) were enrolled in this study. 22 and 20 patients had a history of smoking, respectively. 20 and 22 had a history of alcohol abuse, respectively. All patients had pathological T stage IV with lymph node metastasis, but no distant metastasis. The low, moderate and poor differentiation of the ALT and JF were 0 vs. 0, 28 vs. 26 and 6 vs. 5, respectively. 4 and 6 patients had a history of throat surgery in ALT and JF, respectively. Additionally, the number of the patients with diabetes and hypertension was 8 and 9 in the ALT group while 6 and 5 in the JF group, respectively (Table 1).
As shown in Table 2, the operation times for the ALT flap and JF reconstructions were 365.44 ± 81.57 and 399.58 ± 86.67 min (p = 0.683) with blood losses of 699.37 ± 118.61 and 754.43 ± 104.32 ml (p = 0.198), respectively. The defect size in the two groups was 36.19 ± 11.35 cm2 and 35.58 ± 14.32 cm2, respectively (p = 0.884). Ischemia time of free flap was 86.55 ± 18.43 min and 91.66 ± 21.31 min, respectively (p = 0.692). The size of the repair materials for the ALT flap reconstruction was 126.62 ± 31.27 cm2 and the length of JF was 12.84 ± 4.91 cm. Futhermore, the number of the patients who presented postoperative complications in recipient site and donor site with wound bleeding, wound dehiscence, and wound infection in the ALT flap and JF reconstructions were 5 vs. 4 (p = 1.000), 2 vs. 3 (p = 0.647), 7 vs. 8 (p = 0.770), and 1 vs. 1 (p = 1.000), 0 vs. 0 (p = 1.000), 1 vs. 0 (p = 1.000), respectively. The pharyngocutaneous fistula (p = 0.527), flap compromise (p = 0.663), flap take backs (p = 1.000), partial flap failures (p = 0.674) and total flap failures (p = 1.000) in recipient site were 2 vs. 3, 1 vs. 1, 4 vs. 2, 0 vs. 0, respectively. Number of hypoproteinemia in ALT flap and JF were 23 and 21, respectively (p = 0.408). In addition, the Hospital length of stay (LOS) in two groups were 18.52 ± 6.17 vs. 20.39 ± 7.58 (p = 0.718). ICU stay showed no significant difference between the two groups (Numbers/Days, 1/3, 1/5, p = 1.000). Six months after reconstructions, the number of patients with dysphagia in group ALT flap and group JF was 5 vs. 5 (liquid diet), 6 vs. 7 (partial tube feeding), 3 vs. 1 (total tube feeding), respectively (p = 0.790). The number of patients with dysphagia in two groups was 8 vs. 7 (liquid diet), 8 vs. 7 (partial tube feeding), and 5 vs. 5(total tube feeding) at the 12th month (p = 0.962), respectively. The causes of dysphagia in group ALT flap and group JF with scar contracture, anastomotic stricture, tumor recurrence in 6 months were 3 vs. 4, 3 vs. 3, and 1 vs. 0, respectively (p = 0.814). The above indicators in two groups were 6 vs. 5, 3 vs. 4, and 4 vs. 3 at the 12 months (p = 0.845). Additionally, the remaining patients had satisfactory swallowing function. None of the patients received JF reconstruction had abdominal complications, including ileus, hernia, bowel injury, and abdominal bleeding.
Radiotherapy has become an important modality to treat PESCC. However, for some advanced patients, failure of radiotherapy will cause serious tissue adhesion, and increase the difficulty for radical surgery . Moreover, pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma surgical resection causes large tissue defects, and necrosis and contracture of tissue caused by radiotherapy increases the difficulty of defect reconstruction. The extent of surgical removal of the tumor makes vascular, nerve repair and tissue reconstruction extremely complex. Restoring the physiological functions of the patients' throat, such as swallowing, is a huge challenge [13, 14]. With the development of microsurgery, tissue transfer, and repair methods, including the use of ALT and JF have replaced gastric pull-up in reconstruction [15,16,17].
The jejunal valve has similar lubrication and peristaltic functions to the hypopharynx and esophagus, which is suitable to repair the tissue defect caused by the treatment of PESCC . While the ALT flap, with advantages of soft tissue, rich blood supply, and wide resectable range, has also provided the reconstructive surgeons with an alternative treatment option for complex head and neck defects. However, in our 12-year retrospective study, early surgical repair method was primarily based on JF, whereas in the last five years, ALT had gradually become the primary repair material, probably because the size of the ALT flap simplifies the operation and allows for the adjustment of the size of surface defects on the cutting surface, especially in the head and neck tumors.
It is well known that differences in the time of surgery and the amount of blood loss are also important factors in determining the type of surgery which may affect albumin level in blood. However, for PESCC patients after radiotherapy failure, tissue adhesion makes surgery more complicated, leading to prolonged operation time and increased bleeding, and the time saving of the removal of repair materials and tissue reconstruction becomes crucial. Our results suggested that although ALT and JF were harvested at different sites, there was no difference in operative time or blood loss, while the occurrence of hypoproteinemia was also similar in both ways.
For PESCC, the severity of postoperative complications makes it important to reduce the complication rate for the success of surgery. Postoperative wound infection and bleeding are critical to the survival of free skin flap and microvascular circulation, which determine the short-term prognosis of patients. Our results suggested that there were no differences in wound infection, bleeding and pharyngeal fistula between ALT and JT, which also indicated that short-term complications were not the decisive factors in determining the preference of two repair methods. Although many studies have confirmed that the JF can be used for the reconstruction of head and neck defects, abdominal complications such as intestinal obstruction and bleeding are still the main issue of this flap. The study of Yu et al. demonstrated that one patient developed abdominal hemorrhage, and one patient developed intestinal obstruction due to intussusception in 202 patients with hypopharyngeal defects after jejunal repair . However, the patients in our study who underwent JF repair did not experience abdominal complications.
The primary goal of tissue reconstruction after tumor resection is to repair the continuity of the pharyngeal ducts to maximize the recovery of breathing and swallowing functions. Previous studies have shown that JF is satisfactory in repairing the swallowing function of head and neck tumors [15, 17, 20, 21]. Tan et al. found that a single ALT fascia flap could well repair complex hypopharyngeal, esophageal and anterior cervical skin defects in patients with head and neck tumors . ALT has also achieved excellent results in the reconstruction of head and neck tissues in recent years . In view of the possibility that mass tissue resection caused by tissue adhesion and necrosis of PESCC after radiotherapy failure may have a greater impact on postoperative swallowing function, we evaluated ALT and JF on swallowing function at the 6th and the 12th month postoperatively to improve the accuracy of analyzing the effects of ALT and JF on postoperative swallowing function reconstruction. Our results suggested that although the number of patients with dysphagia including liquid diet, partial tube feeding and total tube feeding in ALT and JF increased gradually with the protract of time, there was no statistical significance between the two groups, which was similar to the results of previous study . However, in previous study, the results of Chan et al. suggested that JF reconstruction of peripharyngectomy defects can achieve better functional outcomes than ALT, which may be different from our results, possibly because our study included patients after radiotherapy and had a small sample size . It is worth mentioning that the cause of postoperative dysphagia in the JF group may be stenosis caused by hypoperfusion at the stump anastomosis, and vasopression may provide better results, which may be helpful for our future treatment.
However, this study has the following limitations: firstly, the sample size may limit the credibility of the conclusion. Secondly, the number of times each patient received radiation therapy was different, which also had an impact on the outcome. In the future, we will expand our sample size and further confirm the results in experiments.
In conclusion, we investigated ALT and JF reconstruction for tissue defect in patients with PESCC after radiotherapy failure. The results showed that the reconstruction with ALT flap was comparable with JF in postoperative complications. ALT flap and JF may all serve as equally safe and feasible alternatives for the patients with PESS after radiotherapy failure.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article.
Pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma
Magnetic resonance imaging
Terlingen LT, Pilz W, Kuijer M, Kremer B, Baijens LW. Diagnosis and treatment of oropharyngeal dysphagia after total laryngectomy with or without pharyngoesophageal reconstruction: systematic review. Head Neck. 2018;40(12):2733–48. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.25508.
Kurita T, Kubo T, Tashima H, Fujii T. Free jejunal flap transfer with multiple vascular pedicles for safe and reliable pharyngoesophageal reconstruction. Head Neck. 2018;40(10):2210–8. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.25313.
Zelken JA, Kang CJ, Huang SF, Liao CT, Tsao CK. Refinements in flap design and inset for pharyngoesophageal reconstruction with free thigh flaps. Microsurgery. 2017;37(2):112–8. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.22432.
Dragovic AF, Caudell JJ, Spencer SA, Carroll WR, Nabell LA, Bonner JA. Locoregional failure and the risk of distant metastasis after modern radiotherapy for head and neck cancer. Head Neck. 2013;35(3):381–7. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.22977.
Kubo T, Kurita T, Tashima H, et al. Free jejunal flap transfer containing multiple vascular pedicles for pharyngoesophageal reconstruction in conjunction with anterior mediastinal tracheostomy. Microsurgery. 2018;38(8):852–9. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.30359.
Takeshita-Monaretti TK, Aguiar-Ricz L, Bastos P, Marques W Jr, Ricz H. Electrophysiological activity of the pharyngoesophageal transition of total laryngectomees. Laryngoscope. 2017;127(6):1369–75. https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.26266.
Hsieh MH, Yang YT, Tsai YJ, Kuo YR, Lin PY. Comparison of the outcomes of free jejunal flap reconstructions of pharyngoesophageal defects in hypopharyngeal cancer and corrosive injury patients. Microsurgery. 2017;37(6):552–7. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.30135.
Mizukami T, Hyodo I, Fukamizu H. Free jejunal flap transfer for pharyngoesophageal reconstruction in patients with intestinal malrotation: two case reports. Microsurgery. 2014;34(7):582–5. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.22248.
Spyropoulou GA, Kuo YR, Chien CY, Yang JC, Jeng SF. Buried anterolateral thigh flap for pharyngoesophageal reconstruction: our method for monitoring. Head Neck. 2009;31(7):882–7. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.21038.
Yu P, Robb GL. Pharyngoesophageal reconstruction with the anterolateral thigh flap: a clinical and functional outcomes study. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2005;116(7):1845–55.
Yu P, Hanasono MM, Skoracki RJ, et al. Pharyngoesophageal reconstruction with the anterolateral thigh flap after total laryngopharyngectomy. Cancer. 2010;116(7):1718–24. https://doi.org/10.1002/cncr.24947.
Hamoir M, Schmitz S, Suarez C, et al. The current role of salvage surgery in recurrent head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Cancers. 2018. https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers10080267.
Song D, Pafitanis G, Pont LEP, et al. Chimeric thoracoacromial artery perforator flap for one-staged reconstruction of complex pharyngoesophageal defects: a single unit experience. Head Neck. 2018;40(2):302–11. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.24962.
Murray DJ, Gilbert RW, Vesely MJ, et al. Functional outcomes and donor site morbidity following circumferential pharyngoesophageal reconstruction using an anterolateral thigh flap and salivary bypass tube. Head Neck. 2007;29(2):147–54. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.20489.
Walker RJ, Parmar S, Praveen P, et al. Jejunal free flap for reconstruction of pharyngeal defects in patients with head and neck cancer-the Birmingham experience. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2014;52(2):106–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2013.11.005.
Li W, Xu Z, Liu F, Huang S, Dai W, Sun C. Vascularized free forearm flap versus free anterolateral thigh perforator flaps for reconstruction in patients with head and neck cancer: assessment of quality of life. Head Neck. 2013;35(12):1808–13. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.23254.
Bianchi B, Ferri A, Ferrari S, et al. The free anterolateral thigh musculocutaneous flap for head and neck reconstruction: one surgeon’s experience in 92 cases. Microsurgery. 2012;32(2):87–95. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.20952.
Yu P, Lewin JS, Reece GP, Robb GL. Comparison of clinical and functional outcomes and hospital costs following pharyngoesophageal reconstruction with the anterolateral thigh free flap versus the jejunal flap. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;117(3):968–74. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.prs.0000200622.13312.d3.
Chan YW, Ng RW, Liu LH, Chung HP, Wei WI. Reconstruction of circumferential pharyngeal defects after tumour resection: reference or preference. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2011;64(8):1022–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjps.2011.03.021.
Temam S, Janot F, Germain M, et al. Functional results with advanced hypopharyngeal carcinoma treated with circular near-total pharyngolaryngectomy and jejunal free-flap repair. Head Neck. 2006;28(1):8–14. https://doi.org/10.1002/hed.20286.
Lawson BR, Moreno MA. Head and neck reconstruction with chimeric anterolateral thigh free flap: indications, outcomes, and technical considerations. Otolaryngology. 2016;154(1):59–65. https://doi.org/10.1177/0194599815606438.
Tan NC, Yeh MC, Shih HS, Nebres RP, Yang JC, Kuo YR. Single free anterolateral thigh flap for simultaneous reconstruction of composite hypopharyngeal and external neck skin defect after head and neck cancer ablation. Microsurgery. 2011;31(7):524–8. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.20906.
Chang TY, Hsiao JR, Lee WT, et al. Esophageal reconstruction after oncological total laryngopharyngoesophagectomy: algorithmic approach. Microsurgery. 2019;39(1):6–13. https://doi.org/10.1002/micr.30304.
This work was supported by grants from the CAMS Innovation Fund for Medical Sciences (CIFMS, 2019-I2M-5-004).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the ethics committee of West China Hospital. Every patient participating in this study signed an informed consent form.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
About this article
Cite this article
Sun, SL., Zhong, B., Zhou, Sz. et al. Comparison between anterolateral thigh free flap and jejunal flap for tissue reconstruction in patients underwent resection of pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma after radiotherapy failure: a retrospective study. BMC Surg 21, 389 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12893-021-01349-2
- Pharyngoesophageal squamous cell carcinoma
- Anterolateral thigh free flap
- Jejunal flap
- Radiotherapy failure