Skip to main content

Table 2 Studies reported on osteotomy methods for cubitus varus in recent 10 year

From: A novel method of lateral closing wedge osteotomy for cubitus varus deformity in children

 

Published (year)

Authors

Cases

Osteotomy method

Fixation materials

Oppenheim’s criteria

1

2019

Yuan-Wei et al. [29]

14

Three-dimensional printing assisted osteotomy guide plate

K-wires

13 Excellent, 1 good

2

2019

Hai et al. [30]

13

Computer simulation with lateral wedge osteotomy

K-wires

10 Excellent, 2 good, 1 fair

3

2019

Karen et al. [31]

1

3D-printed model with lateral wedge osteotomy

K-wires

1 Excellent

4

2018

Hagay et al. [32]

7

Lateral closing wedge (French) osteotomy

Screws and wired

6 Excellent, 1 good

5

2017

Pietro et al. [33]

15

Lateral wedge osteotomy

K-wires and locking angular plate

N/A

6

2017

PARTAP et al. [34]

25

Closed dome osteotomy

K-wires and mini external fixator

N/A

7

2016

Su et al. [14]

25

Lateral closing isosceles triangular osteotomy

K-wires

23 Excellent, 2 good

8

2016

Travis et al. [24]

16

Dual-Planar Osteotomy

K-wires

14 Excellent, 2 good

9

2016

Pankaj et al. [35]

20

Reverse V osteotomy

Cross K-wires and wiring or Y-shaped plate

90% Excellent and 10% good

10

2016

David et al. [9]

90

Lateral closing wedge (French) osteotomy

Screws and wired

84 Good or excellent, 6 poor

11

2016

Ayman et al. [36]

20

Dome osteotomy

Plate or K-wires

Fifteen excellent, five good

12

2016

Takehiko et al. [37]

19

Modified step-cut osteotomy

K- wires

11 Excellent, 8 good

13

2014

Mehmet etc.[38]

14

Lateral closing wedge osteotomy

Methyl Methacrylate External Fixator

N/A

14

2014

Yashwant et al. [22]

10

Modified French osteotomy

Screws and wired

N/A

15

2013

Perajit et al. [39]

18

Double dome osteotomy

K-wires

18 Excellent

16

2013

Hamdy et al. [40]

6

Closed wedge counter shift osteotomy

K-wires

6 Excellent

17

2013

Yukari et al. [11]

30

Computer simulation-based, three-dimensional corrective osteotomy

K-wires

27 Excellent, 3 good

18

2011

Tsuyoshi et al. [13]

N/A

Three-dimensional corrective osteotomy

K-wires

N/A

19

2007

Piskin et al. [23]

23

Distraction osteogenesis

Ilizarov frame fixation

18 Excellent, 5 good

20

2006

Yun et al. [41]

22

Reverse V osteotomy

K-wires and wired

20 Excellent and 2 good

  1. K-wires: Kirschner wires
  2. N/A not applicable