From: The gut microbiota and colorectal surgery outcomes: facts or hype? A narrative review
Author (year) | Sample size | Population | Group/groups | Outcomes | Results | Main findings/hypothesis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohn (1955) [1] | 14 cases | Dogs | 1. 8 dogs -antibiotic at the site of anastomosis and orally (achromycin) 2. 6 dogs – no topical antibiotics | Bowel viability after colic anastomoses with devascularization | 1. 75% dogs had viable colon 2. 100% dogs in the control group died after ischemic perforation | Topic antibiotics help maintaining viability of the ischemic bowel and allow for regeneration |
Abrams (1963) [2] | 44 cases | Mice | 1. Germ-free mice (24 cases) 2. Conventional mice (20 cases) | Status of the ileal mucosa and lamina propria | 1. Lamina propria poor of vessels, lymphocites and mononuclear cells; small Peyer’s patches with low mitotic activity; thin mucosal layer 2. Lamina propria rich of lymphocites, mononuclear and plasma cells; well-represented Peyer’s patches with high mitotic activity; well-represented mucosal layer | GM promotes the trophism of the ileal mucosa |
Schardey (1994) [3] | 57 cases | Mice | 1. Pseudomonas inoculation 2. Controls 3. Decontaminated | AL (esophagojejunal anastomosis) | AL rate: 1. 95% 2. 80% 3. 6% | Bacteria could play a major role in the pathogenesis of AL following gastrectomy |
Okada (1999) [4] | 49 cases | Mice | 1. Germ-free, 2. Conventional 3. monocontamina ted with Lacto- bacillus acidophilus La5 4. Escherichia coli X7 5. ex-germ-free (repopulated) | Anastomotic healing (ileum and colon) | 2. and 5. had higher anastomotic bursting pressure both in the ileum and in the colon compared with the other groups | The establishment of a normal intestinal flora restores the healing capacity of the anastomosis |
Jones (2013) [5] | NA | Drosophila larvae, Mice | Germ-free drosophilia colonized with 6 different bacteria (3 g + and 3 g-); Germ-free wild-type mice vs Nox-1 deficient mice feeded with L. rhamnosus and E. Coli | Response of gut epithelia to different bacteria | Drosophilia’s gut colonized by L. Plantarum shows increased niche cells proliferation.; Germ-free WT mice feeded with L. Rhamnosus have an increased ROS production in the small intestine | Lactobacillus induces ROS production Bacteria-induced ROS production promotes epithelial proliferation and intestinal barrier functions |
Van Praagh (2016) [6] | 16 cases | Human tissue (donuts from colorectal surgery) | 1. Patients who developed AL 2. Patients without AL | AL | Lachnospiraceae family in GM found on the doughnuts is significantly higher in the AL group | Correlation between Lachnospiraceae, BMI and anastomotic leak |
Van Praagh (2019) [7] | 123 cases | Human tissue (donuts from colorectal surgery) | 1. Patients who developed AL 2. Patients without AL 3. Patients treated with C-seal 4. Patients not treated with C-seal | AL | 3. High AL rates. No association between AL and GM 4. AL linked with low microbial diversity, high level of Bacteroidaceae and Lachnospiraceae families | Low microbial diversity of GM is linked with AL in patients not treated with C-Seal |