Non-invasive monitoring of tissue oxygenation during laparoscopic donor nephrectomy
© Crane et al. 2008
Received: 23 October 2007
Accepted: 17 April 2008
Published: 17 April 2008
Skip to main content
© Crane et al. 2008
Received: 23 October 2007
Accepted: 17 April 2008
Published: 17 April 2008
Standard methods for assessment of organ viability during surgery are typically limited to visual cues and tactile feedback in open surgery. However, during laparoscopic surgery, these processes are impaired. This is of particular relevance during laparoscopic renal donation, where the condition of the kidney must be optimized despite considerable manipulation. However, there is no in vivo methodology to monitor renal parenchymal oxygenation during laparoscopic surgery.
We have developed a method for the real time, in vivo, whole organ assessment of tissue oxygenation during laparoscopic nephrectomy to convey meaningful biological data to the surgeon during laparoscopic surgery. We apply the 3-CCD (charge coupled device) camera to monitor qualitatively renal parenchymal oxygenation with potential real-time video capability.
We have validated this methodology in a porcine model across a range of hypoxic conditions, and have then applied the method during clinical laparoscopic donor nephrectomies during clinically relevant pneumoperitoneum. 3-CCD image enhancement produces mean region of interest (ROI) intensity values that can be directly correlated with blood oxygen saturation measurements (R2 > 0.96). The calculated mean ROI intensity values obtained at the beginning of the laparoscopic nephrectomy do not differ significantly from mean ROI intensity values calculated immediately before kidney removal (p > 0.05).
Here, using the 3-CCD camera, we qualitatively monitor tissue oxygenation. This means of assessing intraoperative tissue oxygenation may be a useful method to avoid unintended ischemic injury during laparoscopic surgery. Preliminary results indicate that no significant changes in renal oxygenation occur as a result of pneumoperitoneum.
In the past 10 years the use of living donor kidneys have markedly increased and in 2003 surpassed deceased donors as the predominant source of donor organs . Laparoscopic donor nephrectomy has become a major driving force in increasing the acceptance of living donation. Laparoscopic donor nephrectomy (LDN) is thought to have several potential advantages over open donor nephrectomy (ODN) [1, 2]. Namely, laparoscopic procedures require a shorter hospital stay, decreased amounts of analgesia, allow for a faster return to work and provide improved cosmesis. However, disadvantages of laparoscopic surgery include slightly longer warm ischemic times, and increased incidences of delayed graft function, the later thought to be the result of tissue hypoxia from pneumoperitoneum associated hypoperfusion and organ manipulation [1, 2]. These issues, while minor in most donors, are increasingly problematic in situations utilizing older donors, or organs intended for use in very small children [3, 4]. Many technical aspects of laparoscopic donation have been developed to minimize organ ischemic injury, and several parameters have been monitored to indirectly assess the general tolerance of pneumoperitoneum, including cardiac output, stroke volume, mean arterial pressure, urine output, systemic vascular resistance and end-tidal CO2. All of the methodologies are limited by their inability to assess the organ directly. The most direct measurement would be that of whole organ oxygenation. Unfortunately, to date there has not been a method to evaluate tissue oxygenation laparoscopically in a time frame that is clinically relevant. The ability to intraoperatively monitor renal paranchyemal oxygenation would be useful in a number of clinical situations in which prompt resolution may have a dramatic effect. One such an example is encountered when during the course of the operation the blood supply to the organ becomes impaired by the technical manuevers done during dissection (i.e., approaching the vessels from the posterior aspect). Prompt recognition of decreased oxygenation would allow for repositioning of the kidney and re-establishment of blood flow. Other examples include the determination of secondary renal arteries and the establishment of a baseline acceptable pneumoperiotenum, potentially useful in older donors.
In this report, we describe the development of a means of directly assessing organ oxygenation during laparoscopic surgery. Spectroscopic information obtained by a standard 3-CCD camera used in laparoscopic surgery is processed thereby providing real time feedback to the surgeon using equipment readily available in any standard laparoscopic operating suite.
Porcine experiments (n = 4) were performed as a validation of the sensitivity and correlation of 3-CCD mean intensity values with actual blood and tissue oxygenation. Porcine laparotomies, as part of an animal protocol approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee, were used to assess the extent of ischemic injury (i.e. decreased tissue oxygenation) incurred by reduced fractions of inspired oxygenation (FiO2) during surgery. Standard open surgical techniques were employed to exposure the kidney and renal hilum. Mean region of interest (ROI) values were calculated from the video images of the surgery collected using the 3-CCD camera and compared to measured arterial and venous oxygen saturation values (saO2 and svO2).
For each different FiO2 level, mean values for the ROIs in the images were calculated from rectangles comprised of 900–4,500 pixels. While rectangle sizes varied for each image, the dimensions of a rectangle at a particular location in the image remained relatively consistent from image to image; the orientation of the kidney changed little throughout the determination.
Donor Age (yrs)
OR time (min)
37.1 ± 11.6
25.76 ± 5.03
296 ± 156
294 ± 204
6178 ± 1662
1685 ± 660
For each case and time series of extracted frames, mean values for the ROIs in the images were calculated from rectangles containing at least 625–44,000 pixels. Rectangle size was not consistent image to image because the orientation of the kidney was constantly changing. Glare proved troublesome by contributing false blue regions in the subtracted images; thus, regions of glare were neglected when calculating mean values for the ROIs prior to normalization.
The student's t-test was used to determine significant differences between ROI mean values. Means were considered significantly different with p-values less than 0.05. For comparisons of mean ROI values determined during the pig nephrectomies, a paired t-test for sample means was applied. For comparisons of mean ROI values calculated within the same human surgical case, an unpaired, two-tailed t-test with equal variances was applied.
The described technique was first tested and validated using a porcine model. A fluorescent needle probe (OxyLite) was used to monitor changes in renal oxygenation, alongside 3-CCD assessment. In Figure 2, the solid line follows pO2 levels as the FiO2 level, indicated over the duration of the dashed arrows, is decreased. Figure 2 demonstrates a drop in the pO2 in the kidney each time the percentage of inspired oxygen is decreased, followed by a region of little change (equilibration). Each venous blood draw (BD) is marked by a small increase in pO2; as the blood is drawn from the renal vein, fresh blood flows from the renal artery into the kidney, creating a temporary increase in tissue oxygenation.
Mean intensity normalized ROI values. Mean intensity normalized ROI values of both the start and end time points for each case. All p-values are above 0.05 and indicate the mean ROI values for the start and end time points are not significantly different.
While not presented in this manuscript, we have also examined laparoscopic partial nephrectomies, where complete hilar clamping or renal arterial clamping is performed, and so, we have explored variation in oxygenation as a direct result of surgically-induced vasoconstriction. We do in fact see the mean ROI values decrease after clamping and then return to baseline ROI values after reperfusion (p ≤ 0.05 in all cases).
Donor and recipient serum creatinine levels (pre- and post-operative). Normal serum creatinine levels are ≤ 1.6 mg/dl.
Donor Serum Creatinine (mg/dl)
Recipient Serum Creatinine (mg/dl)
Pre-op day 1
Post-op day 1
Pre-op day 5
Post-op day 10
Recipient blood urea nitrogen values at post-operative days 1, 5 and 20. Normal BUN is 8–20 mg/dl.
Recipient Blood Urea Nitrogen (mg/dl)
Post-op day 1
Post-op day 5
Post-op day 20
This manuscript reports, for the first time, the use of a 3-CCD camera to detect hypoxia in vivo and in doing so, introduces a potential means of avoiding unintended hypoxic injury during laparoscopic surgery. In addition to demonstrating that tissue oxygenation is not impaired during routine donor nephrectomy, the study highlights a novel and useful method for intraoperative functional imaging. As such, this study supports current laparoscopic methodology with CO2 pneumoperitoneum and introduces a method with broad potential as an intraoperative monitoring device.
We chose the open porcine model so that pneumoperitoneum would not be a variable when considering the effect of blood oxygenation on the mean ROI values calculated from the 3-CCD camera. While the equipment employed in this study is used in an open fashion, it is designed for laparoscopic incorporation. An obvious model for altered tissue oxygenation would have been clamping the renal hilum; however, in our hands, it has been extremely difficult to partially clamp the hilum in a controlled fashion (progressive hilar clamping) or to allow the kidney to reperfuse in a controlled and partial manner. Without being able to control the tissue oxygenation or deoxygenation, we could not reliably collect enough data points for a clear correlation. Thus, the decreasing FiO2 model was chosen for our validation experiment. This model directly enabled correlation of oxygen delivery with 3-CCD mean ROI values.
Outside of clinical studies or animal models, intraoperative assessment of tissue oxygenation during LDN is currently limited to visualization of the parenchyma with the naked eye. Although kidney function, in general, has been monitored by creatinine and/or tissue pathology, results from both techniques are not obtained immediately. Further, the use of these assays requires a significant amount of time following injury. In general, as a result of technical variables, laparoscopic nephrectomies require a longer warm ischemia time than open nephrectomies , which may result in additional ischemia as a result of the pneumoperitoneum ; thus, an evaluation of the kidney's viability becomes vital. It is clearly beneficial to be able to monitor the status of the kidney in real time.
Current techniques to assess the kidney during surgery include a non-contact laser tissue blood flowmeter (NCLBF) , pulse oximetry, fluorescein, laser autofluorescence imaging , measuring erythrocyte velocity , and fluorescence oxygen tension measurements [13, 14]. In a study by Ando and coworkers, NCLBF was compared with pulse oximetry and fluorescein for the assessment of ischemic tissue. It was determined that NCBLF outperformed pulse oximetry and fluorescein in accuracy and sensitivity in predicting the viability of ischemic bowel . Pulse oximetry and fluorescein have a high risk of failure for detecting tissue necrosis in addition to a poor accuracy rate for evaluation purposes. The disadvantage of a technique like NCLBF is that the measurement is made via a pencil probe, appropriate for open surgery but not laparoscopic surgery. Laser autofluorescence imaging operates on the assumption that autofluorescence changes with 335 nm excitation are attributed to NADH which accumulates in tissue during ischemia . While the technique shows promising results and allows for real time in vivo imaging, this method requires special instrumentation and is not easily converted to a format for use with a laparoscopic tower. Measurement of erythrocyte velocity using a magnifying endoscope  is the only above-mentioned technique that could be easily applied during a laparoscopic surgery. However, the pencil-lens probe of the endoscope samples and evaluates only a small portion of the tissue during a single measurement. Evaluation of the kidney as a whole would require a large number of sampling points, proving inefficient in a time limited scenario. While the OxyLite probe is very effective for sampling tissue oxygenation within the tissue itself [13, 14], it suffers from the same limitations as the erythrocyte velocity measurements; the needle probe allows for only spot measurements, not global tissue oxygenation measurements. Thus, currently, there are no techniques that are well suited for the diagnosis of tissue viability during laparoscopic surgery.
The technique presented in this manuscript presents real-time capability with straight forward incorporation of additional software and computer interfacing. Real-time function will not require additional hardware or equipment that is not readily available in the operating suite. While glare proves troublesome for some images, inclusion of polarizing optics directly into the laparoscope itself would obviate this problem. Though the technique probes the surface of tissue and is not able to detect tissue oxygenation beneath fatty regions, as in LDN, this obstacle is typically negated by the need for surgical dissection. Similarly, bloody operating fields are only problematic if the entire region of interest is obscured; several small, exposed regions are sufficient for calculating mean ROI values. In addition, surface assessment of tissue oxygenation appears to reflect whole organ oxygenation as evidenced by the large animal data presented herein.
We present preliminary results for a technique that has the potential to diagnose tissue ischemia in real time and in an organ specific manner during laparoscopic surgery. In addition, using this technique we demonstrate that sustained pneumoperitoneum at standard levels (15 mmHg) in a small case series did not have adverse effects on tissue oxygenation as measured by this methodology and substantiated by the clinical course. Although the calculations presented in this study were performed outside of the laparoscopic system, efficient programming will allow automatic, real time incorporation of the calculation to the laparoscopic images. While the clinical utility of this method is still unknown, we recognize that an expanded study, involving a significantly greater number of cases than presented here, would allow the development of a training set by which threshold values for tissue end-point resuscitation could be established. The developed training set would be the foundation for a clinical validation study. Another consideration for the clinical validation would be the addition of a range of pneumoperitoneum pressures, including pressures greater than 15 mm Hg. Furthermore, this technique may be broadly applicable to provide an indicator of organ ischemia during all laparoscopic surgeries.
The authors would like to thank Kambiz Tajkarimi, Ben McHone, Jack Liu and Marie McHenry for their assistance with the porcine model in this experiment. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Navy, Department of Defense, nor the U.S. Government. This work was prepared as part of the official duties of a military service member (E. E.). Title 17 U.S.C. §105 provides that 'Copyright protection under this title is not available for any work of the United States Government.' Title 17 U.S.C. §101 defines a U.S. Government work as a work prepared by a military service member or employee of the U.S. Government as part of that person's official duties. We also acknowledge support from the intramural program of the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of Health.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.